Pork.

A plethora of pork products on display at the stand of Christian Neveux at the Raspail Market (7th arrondissement), 7 Feb. 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
A plethora of pork products on display at the stand of Christian Neveux at the Raspail Market (6th arrondissement), 7 Feb. 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Grimod de la Reynière declared the pig, “King of the base animal kingdom and the one whose empire is the most universal and whose attributes are the least contested.” Indeed, he went so far as to state that without bacon cuisine would not exist at all.

Invitation to Grimod de la Reynière's famously macabre banquet, held on 1 Feb. 1783. Photo courtesy of the Bibliothèque nationale de France.
Invitation to Grimod de la Reynière’s famously macabre banquet, held on 1 Feb. 1783. Photo courtesy of the Bibliothèque nationale de France.

His unfettered enthusiasm for pork should not be interpreted as indicative of his generation but rather as a personal cause célèbre.  Thirty years before he began the Almanach des Gourmands, Grimod featured an enormous array of pork products in the first course of the famously bizarre, funereal banquet that he staged in 1783. His subsequent gastronomic writing consistently treats the pig with reverence, sometimes even speaking of it in anthropomorphic terms.  In his seasonal guide of 1803 he confesses that he hopes his lavish praise of the pig might restore its “so unjustly blackened” reputation.

Pork products on display at the Jeanne d'Arc market (13th arrondissement), 11 March 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Pork products on display at the Jeanne d’Arc market (13th arrondissement), 11 March 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Historically, pork had held a very low status in Europe’s hierarchy of foods. The Renaissance philosopher Marsilio Ficino (1433—99), for example, suggested that pork was most appropriate for, “bodies that are pig-like, as are those of rustic and hardy men.”*  Although such a literal interpretation of humoral dietary theory would have seemed as primitive to Grimod’s generation as it does to our own, such beliefs, so deeply embedded into European culture, lingered just beneath the surface veneer of enlightened thinking.

Even without a medical justification, France’s upper crust had a sniffily disdainful attitude toward the pig, which Grimod made it his quest to eradicate.

What prompted this impassioned mission? It is tempting to infer that so personal an identification with the humble pig may have originated with the fact that his snobbish mother, whom he despised (and the feeling was mutual,) falsely blamed her son’s deformed, claw-like hands on an accidental tumble into a pigpen during his infancy.  Did his almost urgent need to redress the pig’s status derive from this falsehood; the humiliation and disdain he himself suffered because of it; and his anger at his mother for giving him a distorted body and then faulting an innocent, little pig for it? One can but conjecture.

SAM_0056

Leaving psychological speculation aside, Grimod had a very good point to make with regard to French cuisine. Nary a recipe of his era begins without first carefully barding a beast or bird with tiny morsels of bacon. It also often lent its flavor to cabbage and other vegetables.

Sausages on display at the Edgar Quinet market (14th arrondissement), 16 Feb. 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Sausages on display at the Edgar Quinet market (14th arrondissement), 16 Feb. 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Among the pig’s other gifts to gastronomy, Grimod emphasized the enormous range of sausages—both dried and fresh—that in his opinion made the reputation of Paris’s charcutiers. He deemed them the best in the world, owing to their artfulness rather than to the quality of the raw meat, which he credited as being better in Lyon and Troyes.

Many varieties of saucisson sec from Auvergne at the Auguste-Blanqui market (13th arrondissement), 1 March 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Many varieties of saucisson sec from Auvergne at the Auguste-Blanqui market (13th arrondissement), 1 March 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

If barding has gone rather out of fashion in an era of plumper meats and fat-consciousness, Paris still abounds in a vast spectrum of sausages in every imaginable shape, size and flavoring. When the hour for apéritifs arrives, they will likely arrive with thin slices of saucisson sec to nibble on.  But will this be the famed rosette of Lyon; an herbed, rustic version from Auvergne; or come laced with pimento from the French Basque country?

Charcuterie from Franche-Comté on display at the stand of Maison Barbier at the Salon de l'Agriculture, 23 Feb. 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Charcuterie from Franche-Comté on display at the stand of Maison Barbier at the Salon de l’Agriculture, 23 Feb. 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

The two, football-field sized floors filled with food stands from France’s numerous regions that each February feature at Paris’s Salon de L’Agriculture bear witness to the seemingly infinite ways that pork can be cured.

 

Grilled pork chops on apples and onions with Armagnac, 17 Feb. 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Grilled pork chops on apples and onions with Armagnac, 17 Feb. 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Grimod also adored fresh pork. His list of favorites in this category, began with pork chops, grilled absolutely simply. In his honor, I prepared just that with two plump specimens acquired from a butcher at the Grenelle market (15th arrondissement), and served them on a bed of caramelized onions and apples deglazed with Armagnac. On a fiery hot grill, their thick edges formed a crisp crackling above a generous layer of succulent fat.

Dried sausages in front of fresh pigs ears, snouts, feet, and flesh at the Vincent-Auriol market (13th arrondissement), 16 Feb. 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Dried sausages in front of fresh pigs ears, snouts, feet, and flesh at the Vincent-Auriol market (13th arrondissement), 16 Feb. 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Grimod applauded every part of the pig—from the head to the loin. To this day, market stalls and butchers abound in pigs’ feet and ears, shoulders and heads, often piled in heaps directly on the counter.

As in Grimod’s era, ground pork flesh may not only serve as the foundation of a pâté but also, purchased plain or flavored, as forcemeat with which to stuff a bird.

SAM_0611

Grimod reserved special praise for the famed hams of Mainz (in Germany, but under French occupation when Grimod wrote the Almanach) and Bayonne, in southwestern France. Both regions had sufficient fame in this arena to get mentioned in François Rabelais’s Gargantua and Pantagruel of 1534. Both continue to be renowned for this specialty. However, following Grimod’s lead, I will eschew further discussion of ham until April and similarly wait until summer to consider the suckling pig.

Notes:

*Marsilio Ficino, Three Books on Life, trans. Carol V. Kaske and John R. Clark (Tempe, AZ, Medieval and Renaissance Texts and Studies, 1998), p. 181.

(c) Carolin C. Young, 2013.

Posted in January, meat, savory, Winter | Leave a comment

Mutton

Lamb on display at the Saxe-Breteuil market (7th arrondissement), Feb. 18th, 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young
Lamb on display at the Saxe-Breteuil market (7th arrondissement), Feb. 18th, 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young

One of the ways in which the Parisian diet has most changed since Grimod de la Reynière’s day is the consumption of mutton.  In 1803, he described a leg of mutton as, “the most common roast on bourgeois tables.” Currently, one is hard-pressed to find true mutton — being defined as the meat of sheep two years or older in age —even at the numerous Halal butchers that cater to Paris’s large Middle Eastern and North African populations, who esteem the stronger flavor and darker color of the older flesh in their cuisine.

It can purportedly be special ordered it from  butchers such as the Halal farm/abbatoir Kissi on the outskirts of Paris. However, I have never seen it sold in a Parisian market or butcher.

That being said, Grimod himself disliked the Paris-region mutton because he found it both stringy and tough. He advised that, “if one wishes to eat an excellent one, it is necessary to take it from far away and to bring it expressly.” In his opinion, the best came from “the Ardennes, Cabourg, Pré-Salé, and Arles … One could mention afterwards those of Beauvais, Reims, Dieppe, and Avranche.”

The cost of transporting the sheep such a great distance made good mutton prohibitively expensive to all but the richest gourmands. However, in today’s locavore-obsessed culture, it is worth highlighting the fact that in the year 1803 Grimod and his gourmandizing pals felt that the superior flavor and texture of these far-away sheep justified the exorbitant expense of transporting them all the way to the French capital.

Lamb organs at the Boucherie Hamouch at the Aligre market (12th arrondissement), Feb. 5 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Lamb organs at the Boucherie Hamouch at the Aligre market (12th arrondissement), Feb. 5 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Lamb, on the other hand, remains readily available across Paris in a spectrum of cuts. Without much difficulty one can even find the fressure, feet, tongues, and other bits and pieces that get too easily overlooked outside of France.

Grimod, however, felt it to be a “solecism of the kitchen to speak of … [lamb] before Easter.” Therefore, I, too, shall leave off further talk of it until that time.

Read Grimod on mutton here.

Read the original French text here.

(c) Carolin C. Young.

 

Posted in January, meat, savory, Winter | Tagged | Leave a comment

Veal.

 

Veal display at the Raspail market, Jan. 18th 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Veal display at the Raspail market, Jan. 18th 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Grimod de la Reynière unreservedly deemed Paris the best city in the world for veal and I cannot but concur with him.  Although raised on meat from a high-quality butcher in Brooklyn and having indulged in some rather splendid veal-based meals in Italy and other parts of the world, I confess that it wasn’t until I’d eaten veal in Paris that I became a fanatic.

In Grimod’s view, the explanation for the French capital’s superior veal lay in the dual facts that Parisians willingly paid premium prices for their veal (and they still do), which ensured that calves destined for the capital received the best care; and the fact that the city’s officials more rigorously enforced rules governing this tender meat. He especially singled out the prohibition on the sale of meat from calves younger than six weeks old. Younger calves, Grimod explained, have “insipid and watery flesh.”

In his day, Pontoise, about 35 km outside of the city (20 miles), had become the leading center for calve-rearing for the “white veal,” especially beloved by Parisians. He ranked it top on his list of sources for the best veal, followed by Rouen, Caen and Montargis.

Strangely enough, in earlier centuries the veal had come to Paris from even further away. However, the seemingly insatiable demand for it that developed there through the course of the eighteenth century led to the rapid expansion of rearing in Pontoise.  By 1837, Pontoise provided roughly 70% of the city’s veal. However, according to agricultural historian Olivier Fanica, as early as 1844 the new railway lines had already virtually eradicated production there in favor of Gâtinais and Brie, then subsequently Champagne, which remains a large producer.

Today, the region of Corrèze, 480 km south of Paris (300 miles), provides the city’s most prized veal, with the best coming with a “label rouge” guaranteeing that the calf has been nourished exclusively on its mother’s milk. The most sought after of all are delivered straight from the farm. If the origin of Parisian veal has changed, the city’s gourmands remain devotees of the palest veal possible, a factor determined largely by diet.

Grimod’s audience of Parisians in 1803 had a near obsession with the stuff. Over a century-and-a-half later France stood as the world’s largest producer and consumer of veal, with Paris topping the list in the latter category. Now, another forty years on, although overall consumption has fallen, as it has with all red meats, CRÉDOC estimates that the average French adult eats this luxury meat 1.5 times a week — and that statistic again includes the vegetarians who bring down the curve.

Veal kidney at Le Pharamond, March 2007. Photo: Grace O'Sullivan.
Veal kidney at Le Pharamond, March 2007. Photo: Grace O’Sullivan.

Grimod de la Reynière favored the kidney as the most “elegant” portion and that best suited to sophisticated tables.  If that organ has lost its highbrow status, it remains an iconic classic of French cuisine, frequently found on the menus of old-guard restaurants. It’s the sort of hearty dish that merits a nod of approval from bloated old gourmands.

Calves' heads at Rungis, Feb. 26, 2008. Photo: Ami Sioux.
Calves’ heads at Rungis, Feb. 26, 2008. Photo: Ami Sioux.

Tête de veau (calve’s head) hold’s an equally mythic status in French cultural identity.  Grimod conjectured, “but who has not eaten an unembellished calves’ head, simply boiled in its skin and eaten with a sharp sauce?” That would be something of an exaggeration in the current generation; nevertheless, Jacques Chirac not many years ago milked the dish’s symbolic potency to great political effect.  The former French president pointedly and repeatedly cited the dish as his personal favorite (in fact, he’s still doing so in retirement).  Although he was born in Paris, his grandparents hailed from Corrèze. By explaining that a taste for it was in his blood, he connected himself to agrarian France. Beyond that, calf’s head resonated with voters as solid, working-class fare of a distinctly Gallic bent.  Indeed, during the Chirac era a chatty Parisian taxi driver, upon learning that I was interested in French gastronomy, assured me that he placed great confidence in France’s leader because he was a man who loved tête de veau.

In addition to calf’s kidneys, head and liver — items that remain readily available at local cafés and restaurants — Grimod de la Reynière lauded that one could make much with the caul, ears, feet, tongue and even the eyeballs and innards.  Of these latter parts, only the tongue remains commonplace at markets and butchers although the rest can be found with a bit of looking.

SAM_0313

On the other hand, the sweetbreads that Grimod felt appropriate for numerous entrées continue to hold a high status in Paris’s more elevated dining establishments (and a commensurately steep price of about 50 € a kilo from vendors at the outdoor markets). I’m especially fond of bouchées à la reine, purportedly named for queen Marie Leczszynska (1703—1768), wife of Louis XV and daughter of Stanislas, the exiled King of Poland, who employed several notable pastry makers. Bite-sized pieces of sweetbreads together with chicken breast and Paris mushrooms are blanketed in a rich cream sauce and stuffed into individual puff-pastry shells.

Veal roast from the Boucherie de Varenne, Jan. 15th, 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Veal roast from the Boucherie de Varenne, Jan. 15th, 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

For a simpler yet no less delicious standby, any decent Parisian butcher would be happy to cut you a piece of veal roast, which comes expertly tied up with a bit of extra fat around it and ready to pop into the oven.  Last winter I prepared one for a then ten-year-old friend, who sat down somewhat skeptically before this unfamiliar dish.  One bite converted him. “It melts in your mouth like butter,” he declared. Being the true Parisian that he is, he now rates it just below foie gras on his list of all-time favorite foods. Grimod would very much approve.

READ GRIMOD ON VEAL HERE.

READ THE ORIGINAL FRENCH TEXT HERE.

(c) Carolin C. Young, 2013.

Posted in January, meat, savory, Winter | Tagged | Leave a comment

Beef.

Butcher at the Marché Grenelle, Dec. 11th, 2011. Photo courtesy of M. Holden Warren.
Butcher at the Marché Grenelle, Dec. 11th, 2011. Photo courtesy of M. Holden Warren: www.mholdenwarren.com.

Having dispensed with holiday treats as something of an amuse gueule in his introduction to January, Grimod digs heartily into meat, with beef at the top of his list.  This will come as no surprise to anyone who has visited Paris.  Beef plays a starring role in most of the city’s dining establishments, from the humblest café to the most sophisticated restaurant.

The quantities of beef consumed in France have, in fact, declined significantly over the past twenty years. A 2012 study by CRÉDOC (the Centre de Recherche pour l’Étude et l’Observation des Conditions de Vie) estimates that it fell about 15% between 2003 and 2010 alone.

The outbreak of mad cow disease in France in 1996 chipped away at the hegemony of bovine meat consumption. The most notable defector was, of course, chef Alain Passard of Arpège, who had built his reputation as a masterful roaster and who has subsequently retained 3-Michelin-stars with a menu laden with vegetables grown in his dedicated garden.

Customers lining up at Tribolet, Au boeuf du Cantal, a butcher specializing in Auvergnat beef on the rue Montorgueil (2nd arrondissement), Jan. 17th, 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Customers lining up at Tribolet, Au boeuf du Cantal, a butcher specializing in Auvergnat beef on the rue Montorgueil (2nd arrondissement), Jan. 17th, 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Nevertheless, Paris remains a beef-loving town. The current population of French adults over 18 is 90% carnivorous and eats red meat an average of over 3 times a week— and that’s counting the vegetarians, who bring down the curve.

Today’s Parisian gourmands must, no doubt, bolster this statistic, as enticed by the seemingly endless supply of beef designed to appeal to every appetite and price range. At the Relais de l’Entrecôte, with three locations in Paris, the only menu question is “how would you like your steak cooked?”  If the thicker, more lovingly prepared version at the Tonneaux des Halles seems too hearty one can instead opt for their tartare. More delicate appetites might rather head to Restaurant Le Voltaire for a clear but potent consommé.  Or, at the rarified level, Guy Martin keeps an oxtail and truffle parmentier perennially on the menu of the Grand Véfour as a signature classic.

Beef handler at Rungis, Feb. 26th, 2008. Photo courtesy of Ami Sioux.
Beef handler at Rungis, Feb. 26th, 2008. Photo courtesy of Ami Sioux.

The men (and I’ve never seen a woman there) — especially those who handle the fancier French Limousin, Charolais and Aubrac varieties — butchering sides of beef in the meat hall at Rungis (the world’s largest wholesale food market, which provisions the greater Paris region) exude a confidence that implies they see themselves as the veritable kings of the market.

Butcher at Rungis, Feb. 26th 2008. Photo: Ami Sioux.
Butcher at Rungis, Feb. 26th 2008. Photo: Ami Sioux.

In Grimod’s opinion, the best Parisian beef came from Auvergne (still famous for its grass-fed beef) and the Contentin Peninsula in Normandy. (I’ll write more on French breeds, etc. when the cows come to town for the 50th anniversary of the Salon de l’Agriculture, opening on Feb 23rd).  In his day the cattle marched from the provinces straight into the center of the capital to be slaughtered there on the spot.  He compared them to, “stupid youths, whose intelligence does not form and develop, except through traveling,” and believed they did not acquire their true merits except through the long trek that, “caused their fat to melt into their flesh.”

Twenty years before Grimod began his almanac, his one-time friend and mentor Louis Sébastien Mercier penned an impassioned rant against the rivers of blood streaming down the streets of the butchers’ shops.*  He deplored the beef-heavy quotidian diet of “three-quarters and a half” of Parisians whom he felt “almost never” ate fish and rarely consumed vegetables because of their excessive prices.

Grimod, by contrast, exuberantly declared, “Happy Parisians! Congratulate yourselves because, if one must believe in the most gourmand travelers, you eat within your walls the most delectable beef in the universe.”

Gustave Caillebotte, Rib of Beef, 1882, oil on canvas. Private collection.
Gustave Caillebotte, Rib of Beef, 1882, oil on canvas. Private collection.

How did he prefer it? – In an utterly simple guise. The very first specific preparation described in the entire Almanach des gourmands is for sirloin steak, “well-pounded, cooked à l’anglais, which is to say rare.” To accompany this he suggests a sauce featuring anchovies and capers that would not seem amiss on today’s tables.

Following this, he writes about boulli, a term literally translating as “boiled,” and referring to a spectrum of recipes based on boiling meat and veg in water. This produces a gorgeous broth, which is usually served first, in addition to cooking the meat and veg, which are served afterwards.  The primitive act of using fire and water to cook meat and veg together in a pot is thereby elevated into a sophisticated ritual, in which each element, having lent its flavor to the others and enriched the broth, subsequently regains its individuality.

Guillaume Fouace, Pot-au-feu, 1873, oil on canvas. Private collection.
Guillaume Fouace, Pot-au-feu, 1873, oil on canvas. Private collection.

Grimod suggests making a bouilli from the center of the rump, confessing that his choice reflected greater interest in the flavor of the meat than of the broth. He recommends serving it with a “wall” of chopped cabbage cooked in a dark bouillon, large dividers of plump bacon, and a crown of short sausages. For an even more luxurious version, he advises adding symmetrically cut carrots and turnips. However, he confesses that those on more limited budgets would be perfectly content surrounding the rump with potatoes cooked in a good broth and sprinkled with butter sauce.

In playful homage but contrast to Grimod, I prepared an old-fashioned pot-au-feu, arguably the most classic recipe in the lexicon of French home cooking.

Christian Neveux at the Marché Edgar Quinet, Jan. 5th 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Christian Neveux at the Marché Edgar Quinet, Jan. 5th 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

My favorite artisanal tripe/meat/bird man, Christian Neveux  —a fifth generation vendor, with a stand at the outdoor markets at Raspail (6th arrondissement), Edgar Quinet (14th arrondissement) and Maison Blanche (13th arrondissement) — sold me some beautiful pieces of Charolais beef: oxtail and cheek, in addition to the requisite marrow bones.  Eschewing Grimod’s cabbages and potatoes, I purchased the more traditional carrots, turnips, parsnips, celery, leeks, and onions at the nearby stand of Jean-François Dondaine, who grows them in Billainvilliers.

Ingredients for a pot-au-feu, Jan 5th, 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young
Ingredients for a pot-au-feu, Jan 5th, 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young

Also in contrast to Grimod, because I was thinking of the gorgeous broth as much as of the meat, I began by plunking the meat into cold water. After carefully removing the scum multiple times after it boiled, I tossed in the vegetables, which I’d tied in neat bundles for a tidier presentation, together with a bouquet garni.

Course one of the pot-au-feu dinner: bouillon, and marrow on toast. Jan 5th, 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Course one of the pot-au-feu dinner: bouillon, and marrow on toast. Jan 5th, 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

When it had all bubbled gently for several hours the kitchen exuded an aroma so heady that it steamed up the windows. The marrow bones, wrapped in kitchen gauze to preserve every precious morsel, then went in for the last quarter hour.  These I served first with freshly toasted baguette and plenty of course sea salt along with piping-hot bowls of the clarified broth.

Pot-au-feu dinner in Paris, Jan. 5th, 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Pot-au-feu dinner in Paris, Jan. 5th, 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Then came the platters of vegetables and sliced meat accompanied by Maille mustard and crunchy cornichons. It made a substantial but never heavy meal, which perfectly suited a chilly January evening in Paris.

READ GRIMOD ON BEEF HERE.

READ THE ORIGINAL FRENCH TEXT HERE.

 

Notes:

*Louis Sébastien Mercier (1740—1814), French dramatist and writer, composed twelve volumes of essays about Paris from 1781—1788, published as Le Tableau de Paris, which touch upon all manner of observations on life in the capital, revealing a love-hate obsession for the city. The essay on butchers occurs in vol 1, chap. XLII. The subsequent comment about the beef-heavy Parisian diet comes from vol 1, chap. LXVII, Les Halles.

(c) Carolin C. Young, 2013.

Posted in January, meat, Winter | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

January (New Year’s and Epiphany).

Crowds gazing at a display of foies gras and fresh black truffles in the window of the Comptoir de la Gastronomie, 2 Jan. 2013. photo: Carolin C. Young.
Crowds gazing at a display of foies gras and fresh black truffles in the window of the Comptoir de la Gastronomie, 2 Jan. 2013. photo: Carolin C. Young.

Grimod de la Reynière begins his “Nutritional Calendar” with the lavish parties given for the New Year as well as for Twelfth Night. In this respect, contemporary Paris — with the cornucopia of oysters, game birds, foies gras, and sweets that abound at this season in its numerous outdoor markets and plentiful shops— would be utterly recognizable to the old world gourmand.

New Year's chocolates and other sweets in the window of Maison Georges Larnicol, Bd. Saint-Germain; 29 December 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
New Year’s chocolates and other sweets in the window of Maison Georges Larnicol, Bd. Saint-Germain; 29 December 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

As Grimod put it, such gourmand treats grease the wheels of reconciliation during the seemingly endless round of family reunions and obligatory visits since, “it has been proven that … the clouds of indifference and quarrels are never entirely dispersed except by the sun of good food.”

In addition to being a season for entertaining, it is that of gift-giving. The exchange of étrennes, a word used only for gifts offered for this occasion, remains alive and well. If the calculation of how much money to give one’s gardienne (a building caretaker vaguely equivalent to a doorman) becomes a topic nerve-wracking importance, it is not at all unusual for Parisians to offer edible presents to others such as family members, friends, clients or vendors.

Babeth at the Saxe-Breteuil market (7th arrondissement), 18 Feb. 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Babeth at the Saxe-Breteuil market (7th arrondissement), 18 Feb. 2012. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

This year, for example, the ever cheerful but hard-working Babeth, who sells artisanal salts, mustards and condiments in the Grenelle and Saxe-Breteuil markets, gave me a jar of delicious quince jelly that she had made herself.

As Grimod points out, one can accept a gift of food without compunction even though to accept its monetary equivalent would be unacceptable. (And, as he also noted, much that is given as currency gets converted into comestibles in any case).

A gift basket at Foie Gras Luxe, featuring duck foie gras from the Southwest of France, 2 Jan. 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
A gift basket at Foie Gras Luxe, featuring duck foie gras from the Southwest of France, 2 Jan. 2013. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

He favored expensive pâtés of foies gras from Strasbourg and Toulouse, which continue to be perennial favorites. Epicurean shops such as Foie Gras Luxe or the Comptoir de la Gastronomie (both on the rue Montmartre, 1st arrondissement) do a swift New Year’s business in gift baskets centered on these items.

Galettes des rois on display from the award-winning baker Régis Colin, rue Montmartre. Photo: Carolin C. Young.
Galettes des rois on display from the award-winning baker Régis Colin, rue Montmartre. Photo: Carolin C. Young.

Until 1910 Parisian bakers had to comply with an onerous law that required them to give their clients the requisite galette des rois (kings’ cake, with a requisite bean at its center to determine the king of the bean), with which the well-liked holiday of Epiphany, or Twelfth Night has been celebrated since at least the fourteenth century. The abolition of this law, did not, however, diminish the popularity of these pâte feuilletée and frangipane confections, which feature at bakery displays throughout the month.  (I will follow Grimod’s lead by passing over this tradition here, although you can read more about it in my recent article for Zester Daily.)

SAM_0146

Despite a general apathy to sweets that shall become increasingly apparent, Grimod singled out candy as being a particularly popular gift for the season (so-popular that he says that pockets appear transformed into candy boxes).  He seems slightly disparaging of a new fashion for consuming dragées throughout the year because in the past this sweet of medieval origins had been reserved solely for baptisms. Today, they have almost returned to their pre-revolutionary status.

In contemporary Paris, chocolate shops now dominate the sweets-giving trade and the rue des Lombards, which Grimod cited as the center of the candy trade, long ago shifted into a jazz center now dominated by jazz clubs that have now been overrun by tourists.

Posted in January, savory, sweet, Winter | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Grimod’s Introduction to the Almanach des gourmands.

Engraving from the 1803 edition of the Almanach des Gourmands
Engraving from the 1803 edition of the Almanach des Gourmands.

Alexandre-Balthazar-Laurent Grimod de la Reynière (1758—1837) published the first volume of the Almanach des Gourmands exactly two hundred and ten years ago to “enlighten Gourmands in the labyrinth of their gustatory pleasures.” After a dedication and foreword (reproduced here in full in both French and English), Grimod began his guide with a month-by-month list of what to eat and suggestions about the best ways of preparing each product. This blog sets out to follow that advice and to compare what is available in contemporary Paris to what Grimod found in 1803.

What is remarkable, as we shall see, is the degree to which this gastronomic capital relied upon products that arrived from far away. In a later section of the first volume of the Almanach, Grimod specifically states that in spite of being the world’s gastronomic capital not a single kernel of wheat, or even a modest cauliflower was grown in the city. In fact, that had for centuries been the case. And yet, with a centralized food supply system dating back to the twelfth century, Parisians offered up food that made the rest of the world jealous.

Of course, they willingly paid good money for it, as a sixteenth-century ambassador from Venice noted and as is true today.  Arguably, however, no generation cared about it, at least in public, as much as those to whom Grimod addressed the first edition of the Almanach des Gourmands.

When it appeared in 1803 Napoléon Bonaparte was on the ascent. Having declared himself head Consul four years earlier, he would one and a half years later crown himself emperor.  After the tumult of the Revolution and the Terror, and the dreariness of the corrupt Directory, Parisian spirits were high and money was flowing, most especially to a flashy set who liked to dine out, to see and to be seen.

Grimod de la Reynière, with ancien régime hauteur, unapologetically addressed his Almanach to these proto-dandies. An aristocrat of the robe, rather than of the sword, but from an enormously wealthy family (his father’s lavish Parisian hôtel particulier is now the site of the American Embassy in France), he had survived the Revolution and the Terror relatively unscathed because his family had already had him locked away in the south for semi-insanity and he’d slipped out of France during its darkest moments. The fortune, however, had been decimated and what little remained from selling off pictures was controlled by his overbearing mother, who had little affection for a son born with severely defected hands. The Almanach presented an opportunity to sell his old world sophistication with the nouveau riche.

Even in its own day, critics decried its decadence and overt luxuriousness. Within the first year of its publication the Almanach des Gourmands spawned a satirical almanac for “poor devils” that billed itself as a corrective to Grimod’s work. Then, in 1808 Les Annales de l’inanition (the A of starvation) appeared as a “pendant” to Grimod’s Almanach and even falsely stated him as the author.

More recent writers have tended to focus on Grimod’s predilection for complex, heavy dishes that seem not merely decadent but utterly bizarre in the early twenty-first century. Le Monde, for example, recently (3 Nov. 2012) featured an article about a recipe inspired by Grimod’s “roast without parallel,” which appeared in the 1807 Almanach and which consists of a bustard with—stuffed one inside of the other like a set of Russian dolls—a turkey, a goose, a pheasant, a chicken, a young duck, a young guinea fowl, a teal, a woodcock, a partridge, a golden plover, a lapwing, a quail, a dove, a lark, a songbird, a flycatcher, and an olive stuffed with anchovies and capers.

However, if Grimod occasionally flew into ecstasies (especially in later editions of the Almanach) about such fantastical overkill, a final flowering of a long tradition of such exaggerated recipes, the “nutritional calendar,” with which he started his almanac, reveals a preference for simple preparations that showcase the superlative qualities of each food from spring asparagus eaten absolutely plain to wintry game birds roasted on the spit.

This project focuses on this latter streak in Grimod’s writing, which remains as relevant to us today as then, even to those who live far outside of the périphérique.

READ GRIMOD’S INTRO IN ENGLISH.

READ GRIMOD’S INTRO IN FRENCH.

A NOTE ABOUT GRIMOD DE LA REYNIÈRE:

Portrait of Grimod de la Reynière.
Portrait of Grimod de la Reynière.

Although this blog will closely follow Grimod’s words and, it is hoped, thereby allow his personality to shine through, it does not purport to provide a biography.

In English, I recommend:

Macdonogh, Giles. A Palate in Revolution: Grimod de la Reynière and the Almanach des Gourmands. London: Robin Clark, 1987.

French readers can also consult Gustave Desnoiresterres’s Grimod de la Reynière et son groupe (Paris: Didier & Cie, 1877), which can be downloaded from the Bibliothèque nationale de France for free here.

 

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment